Monday, 7 March 2011

Museological Review Materiality Intangibility Special Conference Issue Online!

Museological Review Issue 15, 2011 is now online at http://www.le.ac.uk/ms/research/phdmusrev.html

Contents
Professor Susan Pearce Foreword: Materiality and Intangibility: Contested Zones

Jenniefer Gadsby The Effect of Encouraging Emotional Value in Museum Experiences

Magnus Gestsson and Serena Iervolino Interpreting Art in the Public Sphere: the Ways Display Locations and Strategies Affect the Meaning of an Artwork

Helen Saunderson Intangible Material: Interventionist Art Works

Mary Lester, Joanna Marchant, Ellie Miles and Kathrin Pieren ‘My London’: Exploring Identities Through Audience Participation and Critical Consumption

Robyn McKenzie From the Contested Zone: String Figures in the Museum

Tânia da Fonte Geo-archaeological Research: from 'Drawing a Triangle' to Three Dimensions

Catherine Moore The Material in the Immaterial – The Powell-Cotton Oukwanyama Film Archive and some Contemporary Material Responses among the Community it Depicts

Rebecca Wade The Boundaries of Knowability: Using the Archive to Reconstruct the 1839 Leeds Public Exhibition

J2 'In the Fold' Imagining Words and Image

Tuesday, 20 July 2010

NEW RESOURCES!

Following on from the Symposium, we have put together some resources for organising and holding an event for PhD students. They have been based on our experiences of planning and organising the Symposium and Live Art Event, and we have been (brutally) honest about the process we went through, where we encountered challenges and what we would repeat again if we had the chance to go back in time and learn from our successes and mistakes!

You can locate these resources from the (aptly titled) 'Resources' menu on the side-bar to the right or alternatively click on this link.

Thursday, 17 December 2009

Images from Day 2 (3)














Specifically Helen's 'yarn-bombing' of the Open Museum displays. Does the material become intangible, when we can't see it?

Prize draw winners

Owain Rhys
Rebecca Wade
Anne Putri Yusiani
Jung-Hua Liu
Mari Elliott

- each won a selection of books donated by teaching staff within the School of Museum Studies, plus a £5 voucher to be redeemed on purchases made from the University of Leicester bookshop.

Congratulations all!

Images from Day 2 (2)




Images from Day 2





Tuesday, 15 December 2009

Signing out...for the now.

Right now. It's 6pm, and I think I deserve a break, frankly. I'm going to participate in the World Cafe Evaluation and Prize Drawer. Can I have some final thoughts from you all please? We've had a great deal of fun over the last few days. Please go and enjoy some more...I certainly shall!

Over and ... for a while... out!

And So We Close...

At the end of a rich conference on entangled (im)material objects, Sue Pearce does us the honor of giving the closing address.

Neuroscience, and the sciences more generally, is going to have a huge impact upon the arts in the future. Mind, that intangible thing, is a product of the brain, that 'material thing at the top of our head'. What we usually call intellect or emotion has a physical basis. Thus culture, in all its forms, is material. This has been long understood...is the thought behind it material too?

There is no distinction, Sue Pearce argues, between the immaterial and the material. This has huge social and physical implications. We are animals as physical as they. We might consider ourselves more complex - but don't forget the dolphins!

Every human has about a hundred thousand neurons in their brain, each of which can have a hundred thousand connections. These shift and change, due to the impact of the external world through our senses (each of which senses are complex in their own right), through the collation of experience. These determine our almost infinate levels of experiences.

But this is not a computer. The brain is much messier and more complex than that. Because we are all individuals made up of experiences and memories, our neurological linkages and histories are as particular as we are. It is why one and the same person is capable of good and bad, why we irrationally respond to particular things.

One of our most important ways in which we apprehend the world is through sight. Our eyes, it seems, are capable of generating seven basic patterns. These patterns are grids, spirals, zig zags...the patterns that, across time and space, all cultures recognise. It is why we are capable of understanding, to an extent, each other's art. We may have different linkages in our brains, but they work in the same way - with a little help, the worlds of others can become open to us.

If we are all material, are our morals? Science is beginning to pin down where and when 'morals' began to arise. As cultures evolve (the cultures of ALL animals), co-operation for increased security shows that the material world is part and parcel of the way in which we construct our moral universe. We would stop a child reaching for a saucepan - an act which has both practical and moral aspects. But this is not bleak and deterministic materiality. We retain choices.

Beauty. There are some things which are beautiful across cultures - a nicely plaited cord, for example. It is beautiful and therefore good. It is regular, well made, satisfying.

Much work has been done on touch. As a social mechanism, it is different across societies. As you touch things, a particular area of the brain is engaged which reacts to nothing else.

But where does this leave museums in which we are seldom allowed to touch? The above being the case, there are in those institutions certain modes of information which we can never have access to. So a curator would never give an opinion on a thing without handling it.

There is related to this, a new growth of the idea that the material world can be an active agent too - or even a victim of our materiality. Some physicists are beginning to wonder if there are particles of apprehension or sensation. Is is just possible that we might find ourselves back with a material world in the place wherein we once placed the immaterial, spiritual realm?

It makes me think of stories. As in Mythago Wood, we build individual stories based on archetypes, of mythagos and images which are based in some deep part of our evolutionary past. Did myths, perhaps, always understand this on some level?

Arts and Sciences must begin to co-operate. The artist must prove the validity of their evidence to the scientist, and the scientist must show the artist how their world works. We are not either scientific or artistic creatures...we are just us. Just human. And there is something special about that.

Losing and Finding

The Mary Greg Collection at Manchester Art Gallery is mostly in storage. Since Collections for the Future was produced, a team has been looking into what should be done with such items. The Mary Grey Collection is just such a being - it is historically important, but as a social history collection it doesn't really fit in with the gallery.

So a different kind of interpretation was instigated. This resulted in 'Mary Mary Quite Contrary'...

Mary collected 'curiosities of bygone times'. Many of them have lost histories. The gallery also holds the correspondence that Mary had with the gallery over the period of her life. The array of material is astonishing. How best to engage with this?

The production of the blog Mary Mary Quite Contrary was part of a handover of curatorial control of the collection to the public. This really has begun with the contributions and interpretations of artists Hazel Jones and Sharon Blakey.

These seemingly insignificant objects, keys, spoons, tarnished and worn, the detritus of the everyday, are thus reformed as meaningful...almost magical. They build up a picture of the woman, the real person behind the collection, but also a picture of the museum and it's identity. Who and what we are are thus formed and reformed. The table of artefacts which Liz Mitchell, Alex Woodall along with Hazel and Sharon presented generated so much interest...I think a lot of people may soon be making visits to Manchester!

The Diva Returns...and gives us lightsticks!

The room is lighter this time, but the circle of chairs remains. For what do we wait this time? People respond to lighting so differently now: they are chatting, this time, eating cake and collecting coffee and tea. There is darkness outside, but the room is cheerful. There is laughter and buzz.

Carol Leeming returned to talk about her work, 'The Lonliness of the Long Distance Diva' which, as described yesterday, uses digital visuals, still and animated, poetry and spoken word, a blog, and there will be music as the work evolves. Drawing on the ancient cultures of India, China and Africa, the work is part of Leicester's and the East Midlands' Cultural Olympiad. It is hoped that, in the future, there will be more community involvement as part of a bid to participate in the 2012 Cultural Olympiad.

The work also draws on the history of Ancient Greece and is deeply influenced by the martial arts of all these cultures. Sports, in many cases, were children of wargames and martial practice. Stories of cultures and how these have been handed down and passed through diffusion are also a great point of interest for Carol. Each 'language' contains intangible elements, the successful practice of both often based in a philosophy of reconnection with the intangible self. The Diva of the work, then, is a mythological figure, an embodiment of orality through movement and sound.

Cultures have links across time and geography. Often imagery and stories are repeated and reinterpreted in different locations in different ages and it is through such representation and symbolism that humanity's intangible feelings and experiences are frequently expressed. Through literary and physical metaphor we come at once to understand our world and at the same time to build it anew.

Once again, this access to the artistic process of creation is fascinating, especially given our physical experience of the work in practice yesterday. It brings into more critical relief the experience of yesterday afternoon, without negating our ability to have experienced that. Technology is a huge player in this access, as a new mediator of the flow of energy and information.

And today our own role as mediators is highlighted. We move with lightsticks, we are in and of the music. From our own controlled motion to a directed shaking of the sticks we create intangible forms of light which are part of us, and yet unreal. We share in languages of music and movement, though we may speak them differently. Through these material languages, we produce and pass on the intangible.

Boundaries, Archives, Fragments

The archive of the exhibition is neither complete, nor cohesive - but this is a characteristic of the archive, a device which fragments, selects...and therefore discards...particular traces. The archive is a 'boundary of knowability', rather than the uncontested truth of history. We are, now, beginning to recognise the objects of the archive as such 'traces' and 'fragments'. Rebecca Wade's discussion of the archive of the 1839 Leeds Public Exhibition highlights just these complex facts.

Much of what is saved in archives is the 'officially sanctioned' version. They are records of the power and authority of particular individuals. Where, though, are the other voices? Are there less official resources? Such questions, importantly, do not negate the importance of the offical archive - all material traces are shot through with bias, and it is the recognition of this which validates them as historical records rather than as fiction or propaganda.

This, it is, that the historian must recognise and use. The link between fiction and history, between the storyteller and the historian is deep. Their methodologies and products are often very similar, and even their political and social aims may be seen as such. It is their deployment and reception, however, which is different. Ideologies always impact upon any presentation and there is always a fictive element in any historical construction - documentary and physically reconstructive.

The documentation of transient events can never rebuild the events themselves. Through neither the memories of the perceiver nor officially recorded reports can the in-the-moment-ness of the event ever be recalled. These memories are objects - but they are, as I have said here before, not substitutes for the 'original', but are 'originals' in themselves.

When, where and how does history become fiction, does fiction become myth? When does the document become an object itself? As I was discussing with Kostas over lunch, where does the simulation become an object in its own right and how do we or should we recognise it as such?

Catching-up from Day 1 (3)





Material Responses to Immaterial Things

Catherine Moore The Material in the Immaterial - an archive of 1930s films from Angola and Namibia and contemporary physical and material responses.

Catherine Moore worked as a filmmaker before her return to academia, and so created a recording to accompany her paper. This means she had to time it well - and she did!

How does the immaterial become material? Working on a seventy year old archive of ethnographic film at the Powell-Cotton Museum, she studies how this apparently immaterial data has important haptic qualities and how it manifests itself.

Returning the archive footage the countries in which it was made in 2008, she shows how people responded to the images in so much more than words, the embodied response and 'enactive memory' becoming the focus of her research. Vision, as Merleau-Ponty writes, is 'palpitation with a look'. Visuality is an embodied response to the world, and embodiment is not subordinate to linguistic response. Nor are gestures simply momentary - they are part of a wider experiential and mental whole.

Through a video montage, Catherine aims to challenge widespread notions of ethographic film as purely 'pornography of distance', and through the comparison of the Efundula coming of age ceremony, break down that gap which is sometimes created between the viewer and the viewed subject, by siting the original film next to more modern footage, thus imbuing the older material with contemporary relevance.

This montage encourages the viewer to watch differently, in a more embodied way, to view the recordings as different in their material nature. This, like Mariano's presentation, throws the gaze once more on the process of creation and it's creator. Thus we can come to a memetic, multi-sensory understanding of that we consider 'other' to ourselves.

Catching-up from Day 1 (2)




Catching-up from Day 1




How Do we Perceive Art?

Now we are all happy after lunchtime refreshments, we can begin to consider once again some serious academic type stuff.

We're waiting for a presentation from the Argentinian artist Mariano Molina, who is working with the neuroscience department as part of the Leverhulme Trust's project that studies how we perceive art.

Something that struck me while he was presenting his Wor(l)d, 'Series-Consequences' and Textuals Series, was whether there are distinct psychological differences between how we perceive familiar patterns and more unfamiliar shapes. We read and apprehend a text, for example, very differently than we do a piece of art. But what happens when, as in Mariano's work, that text is transmuted into an artwork itself?

Mariano also produces site specific murals and wall paintings. Again, we see the geographically contingent nature of art, how the location of something at a particular site is inherently bound up in it's meaning.

Gaining Mariano's perspective on his own work is a great opportunity. This is what contemporary art can offer us which more ancient art(efacts) cannot - the ability to engage with the maker directly. While we must not negate the importance of our own, solo, initial experience and response, the possibility of engagement with a producer allows us to engage on another critical level. We are able to see Mariano's method of production, the painting onto a wall of a projected image in an almost photo-realistic format. The deeply personal and solitary nature of artistic production is not always as fixed a form as it might at first seem, access to the artists 'workshop', if you like, giving a completely different point of view. Mariano's work in this vein is exhibited and created in many locations and the same technique can perhaps be seen to have very different effects in different locations.

Even when Mariano uses himself as the subject of his work, he wants to present a character rather than himself. Often, the use of his own physical form is a matter of practical expediency, and the figure that is presented is, he says, not himself, nor does he want it to be recognised as such.

In Mariano's work, the professor of bioengineering at the University of Leicester here, Rodrigo Quian Quiroga, saw possibilities for research, and invited him to be the artist in residence for five months. Mariano's work shows that he understands in an artistic, if not a neuroscientific, format, concepts such as 'focus of attention' and the 'centre of the gaze'. In collaboration with the School of Museum Studies, Professor Quiroga has turned his attention to art perception and infact our very own Jen is a participant in this field of research, which uses eye-tracking equipment to assess how such items are perceived.

Emotions and Objects

Jennifer Gadsby's research focuses on the role of design in creating the value of the visitor's experience. But what is a value? In this case, it is what they seek in coming to the site balanced against what they have invested in making the visit. Mainly, she found, these are emotional, intellectual, interpersonal, physical and social (this last meaning the museum's place in the community).

What stimulates the emotion that a person feels can be anything, and it can be apprehended consciously or unconsciously. Some topics are inherently more emotional than others, yet we still find museums attempting to encourage even more impact upon events which are emotional in themselves.

Jennifer gave post-it notes to the audience, asking them to record how engagement with museums has created emotional effect in them. Sometimes this lies in the design of the museum space, in the interactives that might be engaged with, the dressing and contextualisation of objects in their cases. This dressing of an object can be very inexplicable, and to me, this fact simply highlights that the museum not only takes an object and present it, but recreate it as something new and strange. What is an issue here is not that museums do this, but that sometimes they fail to admit this. Through an admittance of the role that museums play in remaking an object anew (like the Yucatan artists of the previous presentation), the museum can itself become an object of deepening value.

How far should museums 'interfere' in the emotional experience of the visitor? Does such emotional effect impinge upon intellectual experience? Does it undermine them as institutions of learning - or does it simply highlight that they are not the bastions of objectivity that we sometimes think they were considered, but something more subjective and mutable - perhaps even a being with emotions in itself. Museums are, after all, built by, through and for people and we cannot help but feel.